Posts

Showing posts from August, 2018

Specialization and the knowledge barrier (ICC 2018 part 7)

Image
The Q&A at ICC was a bit of a revelation to me.  It's true that some folks expressed their usual opinions, which were mercifully succinct this time, but there were several people we heard from who seemed genuinely confused.  Sometimes they just asked for clarification, and other times, they expressed opinions that seemed to be completely out of sync with the talk that was presented.  I noted one of these questions in my comments on Neal Doran's dinosaur talk, but there were others.  There was another talk all about how X causes Y, and one person got up and complained rather strenuously that the author had discounted the role of X in causing Y.  Yes, I left that intentionally anonymous to protect everyone involved, because it was that bizarre.  It's too bad too, because that was one of the more outstanding presentations of the conference.

All this strangeness got me thinking about the specialization of creationism today.  Personally, I really liked the ICC this time.  …

Panel discussions at the 2018 International Conference on Creationism (ICC 2018 part 6)

Image
This year, the ICC tried something a little different with three panel discussions added to the mix, all focusing on updating research that was initially presented at past ICCs.  The intention was also to focus on areas of uncertainty or disagreement among creationists.  I wasn't sure what to think about it, and I still have some reservations.  But overall, I thought it went fine.

The first panel on Monday afternoon focused on life sciences and identifying the created kinds.  Participants included yours truly, Kurt Wise (Truett-McConnell College), and Jean Lightner (Creation Research Society).  This one was looking  back to baraminology papers from the 1990 conference.  We had a really good time talking about research, and we didn't really argue about anything.  I thought it went pretty well.  I had a good time talking with a bunch of people afterward.  I thought it was really well-received.  (This is the one where I posted the Q&A already.)


The second panel on Tuesday af…

Wednesday at the 2018 International Conference on Creationism (ICC 2018 part 5)

Image
Wednesday was the last day of the conference, and I started out in Andrew Snelling's presentation on radiohalos (that's him in the photo).  If you haven't been following his work, Andrew has taken early work on radiohalos and modified it to fit modern Flood models.   And in case you have no idea what I'm talking about, radiohalos are microscopic stains found in mica that result from radioactive decay of certain elements.  That alone isn't surprising, but the existence of polonium radiohalos is very weird.  The different forms of polonium all have a very short half-life, so they decay extremely rapidly.  So how could enough polonium build up to leave a stain in the form of a radiohalo?  That's the question.

Early work suggested that it must have been a sign of the initial creation of the rock, but it quickly became apparent that that idea was probably wrong.  Polonium radiohalos occur in rocks that were very clearly formed during the Flood, and we can tell that…

Tuesday at the 2018 International Conference on Creationism (ICC 2018 part 4)

Image
Day two at ICC began with a remote presentation from Paul Garner of Biblical Creation Trust, who was in the UK at the time.  Paul planned to come to ICC, but due to unexpected circumstances, he was unable to attend (he's OK now if you're wondering).  Thanks to the convenience of Skype and the ingenuity of the conference organizers, he gave a talk that was almost as good as having him there in person.  That was easily the best remote presentation I've ever experienced at the ICC.

Paul's subject was the Devonian tetrapodomorphs, which is a fancy word for fish that look like they have legs.  Or maybe giant salamanders that look like fish.  It's hard to tell with these guys.  This is yet another one of those big set of intermediates that we find in the fossil record.  Paul and I examined the connection between birds and dinosaurs at the 2013 ICC, and the unnecessarily notorious feathered dinosaur talk at this conference largely confirmed our results.  We also had a pr…

Monday at the 2018 International Conference on Creationism (ICC 2018 part 3)

Image
My Monday began with three talks that I would have liked to hear, but I couldn't because I was scheduled to give one at the same time.  So I'll just have to read about the Precambrian model, the Septuagint chronology, and the long-running Coconino project.  Concurrent sessions at ICC are really not ideal when there are so few of us and we all have wide-ranging interests.  I know ICC has done it this way for years, but we could easily shorten the sessions, have more talks per day, and still have fewer tracks.  Four tracks are too much.  Just a thought.

My morning presentation was given by one of our student interns, and the subject was Cenozoic mammals.  We've gotten to the point in paleontology where a lot more people are trying to do phylogenies of their favorite groups, and consequently, there are a lot more character matrices available in the literature.  So we put together a massive survey of mammalian families to figure out if our statistical baraminology methods wou…

Origins 2018 (ICC 2018 part 2)

Image
Way back in 1999, fresh out of grad school, I organized my first baraminology meeting at Liberty University.  It was a private deal, invitation only, but it launched what eventually became an annual event after the 2003 International Conference on Creationism.  By my count, I have organized seventeen of these conferences over a twenty year period.  We've had ups and downs over that time, but the 2018 conference stands out as a big highlight.

Sitting back and watching former and current students presenting like the young professionals they are was immensely satisfying.  Dr. Blaschke from Union University gave us a marvelous tour of parasitism, which is an enormously important topic for young-age creationists.  Dr. McLain from the Master's University gave us a look at the baraminology of basal mammaliforms (ironically the only baraminology study from that meeting), a project he worked on with one of his students.  We also had a thoughtful presentation on creation research from …

2018 International Conference on Creationism part 1

Image
Last week, I attended the International Conference on Creationism and Origins 2018 in Pittsburgh.  This was my fourth ICC, and I've had papers at three of the four I've attended (2003, 2013, 2018).  I recently wrote about some of my experiences at previous ICCs, and I have to admit that ICC is always kind of a mixed bag of excitement and disappointment.  I'm excited to see everyone, but I always wished that the conference could be, well, better.  I wish the papers were better and the research was better and the progress was better.

In 2018, I felt like I got my wish.

This ICC was notably different.  Very different.  Other people even mentioned it to me.  The papers were more substantive.  There were lots of young people attending and presenting.  Hanging around with students all week, I was energized by their excitement.  Not once did I wander into a paper that was genuinely bad, even the ones that I disagreed with.  This really was a decent conference.

I'm still deli…

New book The Quest is available!

Image
CLICK HERE TO GET YOURS
My new book is now available from Core Academy!  We sold a bunch at the ICC last week, and the early reviews were very positive.  I promise you've never read a creationist book like this one.

The Quest is my own memoir about being a creationist in a world dominated by evolutionary thinking.  I've you've been reading my blog, you'll recognize themes and ideas that I've expressed here, but with a book I get to develop these thoughts a lot more.  I'm told it's readable and accessible even to non-experts.  It's definitely about more than just science and faith.  It's about my life's journey as a believer.  If you like what I've been writing on my blog, you'll probably like The Quest.  You can even read the prologue for a sneak preview!

CLICK HERE TO GET YOURS
Feedback? Email me at toddcharleswood [at] gmail [dot] com. If you enjoyed this article, please consider a contribution to Core Academy of Science. Thank you.